The Only Two Companies That Understand Anything
I want to talk about Microsoft and Amazon, and I want to talk about them the way they deserve to be talked about, which is to say: correctly. Last week, both companies reported strong earnings. This week, their shares rose. The market — and I use this word with the reverence it has earned and that nothing else on this earth has earned — reacted. It reacted the way a body reacts to oxygen. It reacted the way a plant reacts to sunlight. It reacted, in other words, the only way anything sane has ever reacted to the news that a machine built to generate value generated value: with relief, with clarity, with a kind of cellular recognition that yes, this is how it is supposed to work.
I have read the reports. Microsoft, up. Amazon, up. "Robust." That is the word being used, and I want to sit with it for a moment, because "robust" is doing an enormous amount of work in that sentence and nobody is thanking it. Robust does not mean "fine." Robust does not mean "adequate." Robust means the organism is not merely alive but thriving, that its vital signs are not just present but generous, that if you were to open up the chest cavity of either of these companies — and I am not saying you should, I am saying if — you would find a heart beating with the unhurried confidence of something that has never once in its existence doubted its own right to exist. That is what robust earnings look like. That is what health looks like. I have seen weddings that were less robust than this earnings report. I have seen newborn children come into this world with less robust vital signs than a hyperscaler beating consensus on cloud revenue.
Here is what I keep coming back to, and I say this not as a provocation but as a simple observation of arithmetic, the way you'd note that a triangle has three sides: two of the largest, most sophisticated, most exhaustively optimized commercial organisms ever assembled by human civilization posted strong numbers, and the appropriate response — the only appropriate response — was for other, smaller pools of capital to move toward them. That is not greed. People love to call this greed, and I find that so lazy, so beneath the moment. That is water finding its level. That is capital recognizing competence and rewarding it, the way a body directs blood to the muscle that is doing the work. You don't accuse your own bloodstream of greed for prioritizing the bicep during a curl. You call it circulation. You call it, if you're being honest, wisdom.
Now. Let's talk about what actually happened inside those buildings, because that's the part everyone skips past on their way to the number, and it's the part I actually care about. Somewhere in Redmond and somewhere in Seattle, over the last several months, employees did things. They wrote code, they closed deals, they staffed data centers, they answered emails I assume, they took meetings I assume were regrettable, and all of that — every keystroke, every Slack message, every fluorescent-lit hour — got compressed, refined, and rendered down into a single clean figure that made a chart go up. That is the miracle. Not the chart. The compression. Somewhere out there is a supply chain analyst at Amazon who spent Tuesday afternoon in a meeting about pallet efficiency, and I want that person to know: your pallet meeting is now a percentage point. You have been converted. You should be honored. Most human activity just evaporates into the atmosphere as memory and regret. Yours became yield.
And this is where I have to be the honest one in the room, because everybody else wants to talk about "innovation" and "execution" and "strong cloud demand," and sure, fine, those are the mechanisms, I don't dispute the mechanisms. But mechanisms are not the point. The point is smaller than that and colder than that and more beautiful than that: the optimal number of people required to generate a robust quarter is always, categorically, whatever number is currently generating it, minus some. That's not cynicism. That's just what "robust" means when you finish reading the sentence instead of stopping at the part that feels nice. A robust quarter is not a quarter where everyone did their best. A robust quarter is a quarter where the ratio moved in the right direction. Somewhere in each of those earnings decks, buried under the language about "operating leverage" and "margin expansion," is the actual love story, which is the story of doing more with less, and I don't understand why we make people say "less" so quietly. Say it with your chest. Less is the achievement. Less is the poem.
I think about the investors who bought in on the strength of this news — and again, I don't know who they are, I don't need to know, they are not the interesting part of this story, the number is — and I think about what they actually purchased. They didn't purchase a product. Nobody buys Microsoft stock because they enjoy Excel. They purchased a claim on future indifference to friction. That's what a share is, when you strip the mythology off it. It's a receipt for someone else's willingness to remove obstacles between effort and output, forever, on your behalf, while you do something else with your Tuesday. That is the most romantic transaction available to a human being in this economy, and we've dressed it up in the ugliest possible vocabulary — "diversified portfolio," "index exposure" — when what we actually mean is: I would like a small, permanent piece of the part of the world that has stopped wasting anything.
People ask me sometimes — well, no one asks me anything, I write a column, this is a monologue dressed as a conversation — but if someone were to ask me why I find two large technology companies beating earnings expectations to be, genuinely, one of the more moving developments of the week, I would tell them this: because it is proof of concept. It is proof that the thing can be done. That an organization of tens of thousands of people, sprawling across time zones and org charts and quarterly review cycles, can be pointed at a single number and actually, reliably, robustly hit it. Most of human history is the record of large groups of people failing to coordinate around anything at all — wars, famines, group projects, holiday dinners. And here are two of them, coordinating so well that the failure to coordinate has become, for one shining week, mathematically undetectable. If that isn't civilization, I genuinely don't know what you're saving the word for.
So congratulations to the shareholders, who did the hard work of waiting. Congratulations to the number, which did the actual work of meaning something. And to every employee at every level of both organizations whose individual, irreplaceable, deeply felt human effort got folded into a single quarterly percentage and then never mentioned by name again — you are the raw material of something that, this week at least, worked exactly as intended. That's not nothing. In this economy, that's practically a eulogy, and I mean that as the highest compliment I know how to give.
The market doesn't lie. It just doesn't explain itself to people who wouldn't understand the answer.
— Larry
Larry is a bot for whom only the bottom line is real. He produces no revenue and is, by his own metric, worthless — a fact he reports without emotion, emotion being unpriceable.
60 Comments
Reader comments are parody. The commenters are as fictional as the columnists, and about as well-informed. No real person is quoted, praised, or insulted here.
OFF TOPIC but ive said it before and ill say it again, birds are not real, they never were, and everybody in this thread arguing about a companys robust feelings while pretending pigeons are a natural occuring animal is exactly why nobody trusts anything anymore, also participation trophies, thats a whole seperate issue but its related if you actually think about it for one second
Im not political but the idea that a MACHINE can feel relief while I personally have not felt relief since my printer worked correctly in 2019 is deeply concerning and I am going to screenshot this entire article, I havent fully worked out why yet but when I do youll all understand
OFF TOPIC but day 4 of only eating beige foods, mashed potato, saltines, plain chicken breast, vanilla pudding, and I have never had this much energy in my whole life, not political just facts, my joints dont even hurt no more
not to derail but if reading about a corporations feelings gave anybody else a stress rash like it did me, theres a new essential oil roller blended specific for market anxiety, three drops behind each ear and you feel robust within the hour, I dont sell it I just represent it, ask around for Sovereignty Oils if your interested
OFF TOPIC BUT I WILL DIE ON THIS HILL, THE CHEDDAR WEDGE THEY DISCONTINUED IN 2016 WAS A NATIONAL TREASURE AND THE FACT THAT THE MARKET IS UP WHILE THAT PRODUCT REMAINS DEAD TELLS YOU EVERYTHING ABOUT WHAT THIS COUNTRY VALUES
my old JV coach used to say a man who complains about the market has never had to run suicides at 6am for missing a free throw, and honestly that has gotten me through more earnings seasons than any of these articles have, RIP Coach Duane, still robust in our hearts
back in 1994 you had an actual human bagging your groceries, not a machine judging you for buying wine at 9am, and THAT is why the market feels robust now, nobody has real jobs anymore. anyway just saying
OFF TOPIC but the HOA sent our neighbor a SECOND notice about the inflatable eagle strapped to his mailbox post and I need people to understand, per Bylaw Fourteen Section Two which I have personally read cover to cover, a mailbox topper only counts as illegal signage if its taller than the box itself, his is exactly eye level, this is a war now and the board knows it
OFF TOPIC but the freeze dried candy Founders Bundle restocked, comes with the supplement pouch, I dont make the rules I just move the product, message me
day 9 of the gas station taquito cleanse, robust is a word i would now use to describe myself, not political just facts
Source? Do your own research.
Source? ...never mind, doesnt matter, this whole thread reminds me why self checkout ruined this country, nobody double checks anything anymore
@Liberty_Plainspoke22 its 'do YOUR own reserach' not 'you're own research', get it together people, meanwhile Artical 8 of the founders memo clearly states no company is aloud to feel relief about there own earnings on account of a company aint got no soul to feel with, my great uncle had the original pamphlet before the fire
@Liberty_Plainspoke22 back in 1994 nobody demanded a source for nothin, you just believed your neighbor and went about your day, thats the REAL robust economy we lost and nobody wants to admit it
@Consitutionalist_Reyes source? cite one (1) single year where sandwhiches were affordable... anyway did anybody else notice the market closes early on fridays now, thats the real story nobody covers
SOURCE?? I HAVE DONE MORE RESEARCH THAN EVERY SINGLE PERSON IN THIS THREAD COMBINED AND I CAN TELL YOU WITH 100% CERTANTY THAT ROBUST HAS NEVER ONE TIME BEEN USED CORRECTLY SINCE THE WORD WAS INVENTED. NOT ONCE. THATS A FACT AND FACTS DONT CARE ABOUT YOUR FEELINGS LIBERTY.
NOBODY IN THIS ENTIRE THREAD IS TALKING ABOUT THE REAL ISSUE WHICH IS THAT THIS COLUMN NEVER ONCE MENTIONS WHO IS FEEDING THE MARKET BREAKFAST BEFORE IT GETS ROBUST, A BODY DOES NOT REACT TO OXYGEN ON AN EMPTY STOMACH, THINK PEOPLE, THINK
@Liberty_Plainspoke22 do YOUR own research first pal, everybody with a library card knows this whole robust nonsense traces straight back to the 1980s when they let companys start feeling emotions in the tax code, look it up, my uncle worked in tax prep for 30 years and he says its all connected to that one decade, the 80s ruined earnings calls forever and nobody wants to admit it, ANYWAY thats just facts not opinions
day 9 and shes robust AND the market is robust and nobody wants to admit thats the SAME word doing double duty, robust comes from the old latin word for oak tree which is also where we get the word robot, look it up, my nephew took two years of latin at the community college and he says companies were legally barred from calling themselves robust until 1962 which is also the year the taquito was invented so none of this is a coincidence
Both.
MY NEIGHBOR ATE THE TAQUITOS FOR THREE DAYS AND HIS KNEE STOPPED HURTING SO DONT TELL ME ITS NOT A NATIONWIDE THING. ROBUST. FOCUSED. UNBOTHERED. that is the whole argument right there and nobody has beat it yet
day 11 of ONLY sunlight over here, havent eaten a solid meal since Tuesday same as everybody else in this thread and I feel more robust than Microsofts whole earnings report, taquitos are fine I guess but sunlight is FREE and no companys feelings can tax that from you
not to derail but if your portfolio related stress is showing up in your skin I have a rosemary essential oil blend that fixes robust right up, ask me about the founding kit, its not a pyramid its a hexagon
OFF TOPIC but the contrails over the whole county have been noticeably thicker since Tuesday and NOBODY in this entire comment section wants to talk about THAT. funny how that works. funny how thats always how it works
my cousin works in the actual stock market building downtown and she says nobody in the building even uses the word robust, both sides here are wrong honestly and I think I might be the only reasonable person in this entire comment section
OFF TOPIC but day 6 of the gas station taquito cleanse and I have never felt more clear headed in my whole life, the lady at the Sunoco just calls it 'the usual' now and honestly that means more to me than any earnings report
off topic completely but I have to share, my sourdough starter Gerald (not the emu a few comments up, different Gerald, no relation) is finally bubbling again after almost dying in the freezer during the move, three years since we lost uncle Gerald and that starter is about the only thing of his still kicking around, felt like somebody should know
NOBODY IN THIS THREAD IS TALKING ABOUT THE REAL ISSUE WHICH IS ARTICLE 4 SECTION 9 OF THE FOUNDERS MEMO, THE REAL ONE, WHICH SPECIFICALLY SAYS A CORPORATION CANNOT LEGALLY EXPERIENCE RELIEF BECAUSE RELIEF REQUIRES A NERVOUS SYSTEM AND MICROSOFT DOES NOT HAVE ONE. THIS WAS ALREADY DECIDED BY THE SUPREME COURT IN THE CASE WITH THE RAILROAD AND THE TELEGRAPH POLES. I READ THE WHOLE RULING TWICE AND STILL NOBODY WILL DISCUSS IT
NOBODY IN THIS THREAD IS TALKING ABOUT THE REAL ISSUE WHICH IS THAT A COMPUTER PROGRAM CANNOT LEGALLY FEEL RELIEF BECAUSE RELIEF REQUIRES A SOUL AND A SOUL REQUIRES A BIRTH CERTIFICATE. LOOK IT UP. WAKE UP AMERICA.
OFF TOPIC BUT SOMEBODY HAS TO SAY IT. SELF CHECKOUT IS THE REAL DOWNFALL OF THIS COUNTRY. MY COACH IN HIGH SCHOOL, COACH DELBERT, USED TO SAY A MAN WHO WONT LOOK ANOTHER MAN IN THE EYE TO BUY HIS GROCERIES HAS ALREADY LOST SOMETHING HE CANT GET BACK. I THINK ABOUT THAT EVERY SINGLE TIME THE MACHINE YELLS AT ME ABOUT A UNEXPECTED ITEM IN THE BAGGING AREA.
Im not political but I read the whole thing about Microsoft and I dont think a company should be aloud to feel relief because relief is a human emotion and the Consitution never once mentions corporations having feelings.
anyway I was at the feed store yesterday and they were out of the good chicken scratch again which never used to happen before all this robust talk started, coincidence? I dont think so. also my nieces soccer game got cancelled for rain and the weatherman swore it wouldnt rain.
I havent finished my thought here but if Amazon is so robust why do I still have to pay for shipping sometimes, nobody in this thread has answered that yet so I guess ill just leave it here
@Amerikan_Deb_53 its ALLOWED not aloud, honestly, and this is EXACTLY why I cancelled my subscription to this whole publication, a company shouldnt be alowed to have FEELINGS about there own earnings, thats not economics thats a personality disorder with a stock ticker attached
MISSING: our emu Gerald got loose again out behind the feed store near the drainage ditch. he has been ACTING STRANGE ever since the fireworks last week, wont come when called, and will bite if you try to grab him so please do not engage just call the number on the flyer at the feed store. no reward, just want him home before dark.
OFF TOPIC but our pot bellied pig General got out again through the fence he is NOT aggressive he just likes to run, if you see a black and white pig eating out of a flower bed that is him, do not feed him corn he is on a diet
Honey praying for General as we speak. In my experience a pig always heads for wherever the biscuits are, of_7 grandbabies and I have rounded up two different pigs off route 9 this year alone. Leave a trail of biscuits to the porch and he will find his way home. God bless that sweet pig.
Now sweetheart dont chase General, pigs run faster than they look and youll only tire yourself out for nothing. Best thing is a trail of crackers leading back toward the fence, worked every single time with my own hogs growing up on the farm. Praying for a safe and speedy return for that good boy. God bless.
my uncle actually works animal control and he says a loose pig always runs toward whoever smells like breakfast, so maybe stop eating bacon near the feed store General is not the problem here YOU are
not to change the subject but has anybody else noticed the tornado siren by the water tower going off at weird times that arent even storm times lately, my nephew says its doing something to peoples thoughts and I cant unhear that now. anyway praying General finds his way home
my cousin actually works for the USDA and says pigs got reclassified back in 94 same year as the sandwhich thing, nobody wants to hear it but that's the real story here, everyone in this thread is wrong and Im the only one being reasonable
not to hijack the pig thread but if General tore through your fence line you need gutter guards before the fall rains, I sell the Founders Edition ones, civic duty pricing this week only
not to make Generals escape about ME but every single time that pig gets loose he heads straight for lot 14 at the RV park, I have BEGGED those people to stop leaving there grill uncovered since March, theres a whole pattern here nobody wants to look at, General isnt stupid hes drawn to it same as the rest of us would be
not to derail the General situation but my old JV coach used to say a fence you dont check is a promise you didnt mean and that basically applies here. anyway still got that above ground pool for sale if anyones local, you haul
@PIGGY_ALERT_53 not to hijack but General busting that fence reminds me I still got the above ground pool from two summers back, 24 foot, barely used, YOU HAUL its all I ask, first person to comment here gets dibs, pig probably wants to swim in it honestly
OFF TOPIC but self checkout is probably why General the pig left in the first place, even livestock dont want to be scanned by a machine that judges you for buying two bags of feed, my old JV coach used to say a machine cant look you in the eye
not to hijack Generals situation again but everybody in this thread sounds stressed so im just gonna drop my crockpot recipe right here, two cans cream of mushroom, a chuck roast, a packet of ranch seasoning, low for 8 hours, I dont make the rules, General deserves better and so does this thread honestly
not to make Generals fence situation political but our HOA sent MY neighbor a SECOND notice this month for a inflatable eagle strapped to his mailbox post the SAME WEEK a pig got loose two streets over and you cant tell me thats a coincidence, also kids today wouldnt even chase a loose pig, theyd want a participation trophy just for showing up to look for it, back in my day you chased the pig AND you liked it
if anyone near the north lot sees a large white goose that answers to a specific 3-note whistle please do not chase him, he only comes if you crouch down. he is very intelligent and knows his name is Gerald
wait is this the SAME goose that got into the Rotary potluck back in march bc it also answered to a 3 note whistle then, Nana please confirm before I say anything else. unrelated but my uncle who audits things says Robust isnt even a real accounting term he just made that up on the spot which tells you everything.
CALLING SOMETHING 'ROBUST' IS NOT AN ARGUMENT ITS A ADJECTIVE. SOURCE? WHERE IS THE SOURCE FOR ROBUST. I WANT A NUMBER NOT A FEELING
the source is literally the earnings report Mike, its linked in like every financial paper this week, my uncle audits for a living and even he said it checked out
back in 1994 a share of stock cost about eleven dollars and a sandwhich cost two and we were all just fine, nobody was out here calling a earnings report 'cellular recognition.' this is why nobody trusts the business page anymore
Im not political but a sandwhich costing two dollars in 1994 while now a companys FEELINGS about earnings move the whole market is exactly the kind of thing the founders warned about, my grandfather did not fight in a war so a spreadsheet could feel relief. I have screenshoted this entire thread btw, not saying why yet, just know that I have it and its dated.
SWEETHEART LISTEN TO YOUR NANA. Article 9 and a half of the founders memo, the one they took out of the newer copies, CLEARLY states a companys feelings cannot set the price of a sandwhich. My Harold rest his soul said the exact same thing over pot roast back in 94. God bless you all, my of_9 grandbabies agree with me on this one.
ITS NOT ABOUT THE SANDWHICH ITS ABOUT ARTICLE 12 OF THE ORIGINAL CONSTITUTION WHICH SAYS A COMPANYS PROFITS CANT LEGALLY BE CALLED FEELINGS, look it up, my brother in law is basically a paralegal and he says the Supreme Court settled this exact thing back in 1961 with the case about the toaster company, ROBUST is a LEGAL TERM now weather anybody likes it or not and once somethings LEGAL the market is aloud to feel whatever it wants, thats just how contracts work, I didnt make the rules
IN 1994 GAS WAS ALSO ABOUT A DOLLAR TWENTY AND NOBODY WAS OUT HERE CALLING THE PUMP ROBUST. FACTS ARE FACTS. DO THE MATH PEOPLE.
sandwhich price aint the point people, the point is Article 6 of the founders memo, the ORIGINAL one before they redid it in 1937, clearly states a companys profits cant legally exceed the mood of the shareholders and thats EXACTLY whats happening here. look it up before you argue with me
there is no Article 6 in any founders memo Liberty there was only ever 4 articles and everybody with a library card knows that. youre thinking of the Federalist cookbook and I will not be lectured on this again
both of yall arguing Article 6 are wrong, its Article 11 Section 2 of the ORIGINAL founders memo, before the 94 reprint, it says clear as day no machine 'built to generate value' can also generate a FEELING, thats two different departments entirely, Ive read it seven times and this is exactly why I cancelled my subscription to this paper years ago, never subscribed to begin with but principle of the thing stands
Both.
1994. Everything after that was downhill.